Gilberto Silva Player Review
Pros
Elite defensive reliability
Gilberto Silva is outstanding defensively. His interceptions and positional awareness are top class, allowing him to shield the backline effectively and break up attacks before they become dangerous.
Excellent tackling
His standing and sliding tackles are very clean and consistent. He wins the ball confidently in one-on-one situations and rarely mistimes challenges.
Strong marking ability
He tracks attackers tightly and limits their space. His marking makes him very dependable when protecting the defensive line.
Dominant physical presence
Physically very strong and aggression-minded, Gilberto Silva controls midfield duels with ease. He stands firm in challenges and is hard to bypass physically.
Very good pace
His sprint speed and acceleration feel better than expected for a CDM. He covers ground well and can recover quickly during transitions.
Reliable passing and build-up play
His passing and crossing are solid. He keeps play moving smoothly, supports buildup, and distributes the ball safely from deep positions.
Good height and aerial presence
At 6.1, he has a strong physical presence that helps in defensive battles and aerial duels, making him more complete as a holding midfielder.
Positional versatility
He can play as a CM without any OVR drop. Even in that role, he maintains strong shape, discipline, and balance between defense and support play.
Cons
Weak foot could be better
A 5* weak foot would have made him more complete, but 4* is still acceptable for a CDM and doesn’t cause major issues.
Limited skill moves
With only 3* skill moves, he offers less creativity on the ball. He is more focused on control and stability rather than flair.
No special traits
He lacks special traits, which means he doesn’t get extra gameplay boosts compared to some elite CDMs with trait advantages.
Conclusion
Gilberto Silva is a rock-solid defensive midfielder with elite tackling, strong physicality, good pace, and excellent positioning. He may not be flashy, but his consistency and defensive control make him an extremely effective option for stabilizing midfield.
Rating 9.9/10